0
0
No. The sentence “God doesn’t make mistakes” is not in the Bible. The word “mistake” never appears in the King James Bible, not once in any of its 31,102 verses. Search it and you get nothing. So if you are asking “is God doesn’t make mistakes in the Bible,” the honest answer is: not in those words.
But the idea is in there, and it is close. Deuteronomy 32:4 says of God, “his work is perfect.” Psalm 18:30 says “his way is perfect.” The saying is a short, modern, child-sized version of those verses. The wording is ours. The thought is older than us.
That matters, because the Bible’s own version is more careful than our version, and the care is the whole point. Keep reading and you will see why.
Where “God doesn’t make mistakes” came from
Nobody owns this one. I could not find a first author, and no source I checked claims one. It is not a quote. It is a paraphrase that grew up around a verse, the way moss grows on a stone.
Here is the oldest use I could find, and it is a lovely one. A Victorian preaching anthology called The Biblical Illustrator, compiled by Joseph Exell and published from the late 1880s, carries a short anonymous story under 2 Samuel 22:31. That verse reads, “As for God, his way is perfect.” In the story, a child hears the verse and asks, “Papa, doesn’t it mean that God makes no mistakes?”
So the earliest trace I can find of the saying is a child turning a verse into plain words. That is exactly what the saying is. It is the verse, made simple enough for a child. There is nothing wrong with that. It only becomes a problem when we forget the verse and keep the simple words.
From there the line travelled the way sayings travel: by being useful.
- In 1975, Evelyn Christenson used “God Never Makes a Mistake” as a chapter title in her book What Happens When Women Pray.
- In 2004, Loretta Lynn wrote and sang “God Makes No Mistakes,” the closing song on her album Van Lear Rose. The song asks why a child is born blind and why a cruel man outlives a loving father, and answers that God’s purposes are not ours to question.
- In 2011, Lady Gaga’s “Born This Way” put a line about God making no mistakes into the chorus of a number-one single. She later said the song was inspired by Carl Bean’s 1977 song “I Was Born This Way.”
Notice what those three have in common. A prayer book, a country song, and a pop anthem all reach for the same five words at the same moment: when someone is looking at a body, or a life, that the world has called wrong. “God doesn’t make mistakes” is almost always said about a person. That is a clue to what it really means, and we will come back to it.
You might also hear it as “God makes no mistakes,” “God never makes a mistake,” or “God don’t make mistakes.” Same saying, same story.
What the Bible actually says instead
The closest verse is Deuteronomy 32:4, and it is worth knowing who said it and when.
“He is the Rock, his work is perfect: for all his ways are judgment: a God of truth and without iniquity, just and right is he.” (Deuteronomy 32:4, KJV)
Those are Moses’s words. Deuteronomy 31:30 says he “spake in the ears of all the congregation of Israel the words of this song.” And Deuteronomy 32:48 says that “that selfsame day” God told Moses to climb Mount Nebo, look at the promised land, “and die in the mount.”
Read that again. Moses sang “his work is perfect” on the day he was told he would die without walking into the land he had spent forty years walking toward. He was not saying it from a poster. He was saying it from the edge of his own unanswered prayer.
That is the first thing the Bible’s version has that our version lacks. It is spoken by someone who has lost, not to someone who has lost.
The second thing is bigger. Our saying folds two very different claims into one sentence.
Claim one: you are not a mistake. The Bible says this plainly, and says it about the body. “I will praise thee; for I am fearfully and wonderfully made” (Psalm 139:14, KJV). When Moses said he could not speak well, God answered, “Who hath made man’s mouth? or who maketh the dumb, or deaf, or the seeing, or the blind? have not I the LORD?” (Exodus 4:11, KJV). The Bible does not treat a deaf person or a blind person as a flaw in the design. It puts God’s own name on their making.
Claim two: nothing that happens to you is a mistake. Here the Bible is much more careful than we are. It is not trying to hand us a slogan. In the King James wording, Genesis 6:6 says “it repented the LORD that he had made man on the earth, and it grieved him at his heart.” And Numbers 23:19 says “God is not a man, that he should lie; neither the son of man, that he should repent.” The Bible holds both of those lines without flinching. It is willing to say God is perfect and that God grieves in the same book.
And then there is what Jesus did with the question. In John 9, His disciples saw a man blind from birth and asked who had sinned, the man or his parents. Jesus said, “Neither hath this man sinned, nor his parents: but that the works of God should be made manifest in him” (John 9:3, KJV). Then He healed him. Jesus refused to explain the blindness as anyone’s fault. He also refused to leave it alone.
That is the pattern. The Bible never says a disability or a death is “not a mistake” and then walks away. At the grave of a friend, with the resurrection minutes away, the shortest verse in the King James Bible is still “Jesus wept” (John 11:35, KJV).
Why the difference matters
“God doesn’t make mistakes” gets said in two places more than anywhere else: at a hospital bed and at a kitchen table. It is said to parents whose baby has died. It is said to people whose bodies do not work the way other bodies do. It is said to people who have started to wonder whether they themselves are the error.
It can be a rock. Vaneetha Rendall Risner, who had polio as a baby and later lost her two-month-old son, has written that when she first saw “God Never Makes a Mistake” as that 1975 chapter title she found it trite and naive, and assumed the author had never suffered. Years later, after her son’s death, she came to call the same words a truth she could build her life on. Nobody said it to her. She arrived at it.
That is the difference. Said by the person who is suffering, after a long road, the line is faith. Said to the person who is suffering, in the first week, it can land as a door closing. It answers a question they did not ask, “did God slip up?”, and it quietly forbids the one they did ask, which is “why?” A grieving mother is not usually wondering whether God is competent. She is wondering whether God is kind. The saying answers the wrong question.
And because the Bible’s own version is spoken by Moses from his own loss, not aimed at someone else’s, the real thing is safer than the folk version. The real thing is a song a dying man sang. It is not a correction handed to a crying one.
If you have said “God doesn’t make mistakes” to someone in pain, you were not wrong and you were not unkind. Almost all of us have said it, and most of us meant claim one, “you are not a mistake,” which the Bible says louder than we do. The only lesson here is about timing and direction. The Bible’s first move at a grave was tears, not a verse. Ours can be too.
This is a close cousin of two other sayings we have looked at, “God gives his hardest battles to his strongest soldiers” and “forgive and forget”. All three are things we say to make a hard moment smaller. All three turn out to be bigger, and kinder, in the Bible’s own words. And if you are in that hard moment yourself right now, this short “what stage of grief am I in?” check was built for exactly that week.
A short prayer for someone who was told this
God, I was told that You do not make mistakes, and I wanted to believe it, and some days I could not. I am not asking You to prove You are perfect. I am asking whether You are near. Moses sang about Your perfect work on the day he learned he would not get what he prayed for. Let me sing it like that, from inside the loss, in my own time, and not because someone needed me to stop crying. Thank You that Jesus wept before He did anything else. Amen.
Which other sayings did you think were in the Bible?
Which saying did you believe was a Bible verse for years before you found out it was not? And who said it to you? I would love to hear it in the comments. Those stories are where the next article comes from.
Social Share Posts
“I just found out ‘God doesn’t make mistakes’ is not actually a Bible verse. The word ‘mistake’ is not in the King James Bible at all. The closest verse was sung by Moses on the day he learned he would die before reaching the promised land. That changes how I hear it.”
“Someone said ‘God doesn’t make mistakes’ to me in the worst week of my life. Turns out it is not in the Bible. The verse it comes from, Deuteronomy 32:4, was spoken by a man about his own loss, not aimed at someone else’s. I had no idea.”
“The oldest trace anyone can find of ‘God makes no mistakes’ is a child in an 1880s sermon book asking if that is what ‘his way is perfect’ means. It was always a child’s version of a verse. Knowing that makes me hold it more gently.”
Q&A
Is “God doesn’t make mistakes” in the Bible?
No. “God doesn’t make mistakes” is not a Bible verse, and the word “mistake” never appears in the King James Bible. The idea comes from verses like Deuteronomy 32:4, “his work is perfect,” and Psalm 18:30, “his way is perfect.” The saying is a modern, simplified paraphrase of those verses, not a quotation of any of them.
What Bible verse says God makes no mistakes?
No Bible verse says “God makes no mistakes” in those words. The closest verses are Deuteronomy 32:4, “He is the Rock, his work is perfect: for all his ways are judgment,” and Psalm 18:30 and 2 Samuel 22:31, which both say “As for God, his way is perfect.” Numbers 23:19 adds that God “is not a man, that he should lie.” These verses say God’s ways are perfect and true. None of them uses the word “mistake.”
Who first said “God doesn’t make mistakes”?
Nobody knows who first said “God doesn’t make mistakes,” and no source credibly claims a first author. The oldest use I could find is an anonymous story in a Victorian preaching anthology, The Biblical Illustrator, compiled by Joseph Exell in the late 1800s, in which a child asks whether 2 Samuel 22:31 means “God makes no mistakes.” Later well-known uses include a 1975 chapter title in Evelyn Christenson’s What Happens When Women Pray, Loretta Lynn’s 2004 song “God Makes No Mistakes,” and the chorus of Lady Gaga’s 2011 single “Born This Way.”
Is it wrong to say “God doesn’t make mistakes” to someone who is grieving?
It is not wrong, but it is often badly timed. “God doesn’t make mistakes” answers a question a grieving person is usually not asking, whether God slipped up, and can shut down the question they are asking, which is why. The Bible’s closest verse, Deuteronomy 32:4, was sung by Moses about his own loss, on the day he learned he would die before entering the promised land. The Bible’s first response at a grave is “Jesus wept” (John 11:35). Tears first, verses later, is the pattern scripture itself follows.
Does the Bible say disabled people are not a mistake?
Yes, in effect. The Bible never uses the word “mistake,” but it puts God’s own name on the making of people with disabilities. In Exodus 4:11 God says, “who maketh the dumb, or deaf, or the seeing, or the blind? have not I the LORD?” In John 9:3 Jesus refuses to blame a man’s blindness on anyone’s sin, saying it was “that the works of God should be made manifest in him,” and then heals him. Psalm 139:14 says every person is “fearfully and wonderfully made.”
