0
0
You had a rough day. You open the app, scroll for a while, and twenty minutes later something is on its way to you. And you really do feel better. Lighter. Like you did something.
Then the box arrives. You open it on the kitchen table, lift the thing out, look at it, and feel… not much. Maybe a small flicker. Maybe a bit of guilt. Mostly you feel like you did before you bought it.
That is retail therapy, and it is real. So is the flat feeling that comes after. Researchers have actually studied both ends of this curve, and what they found is not what most of us assume. The good part is not where you think it is. And once you know where it lives, you can get it without the box.
Retail Therapy Is Real, and the Relief Is Not in the Buying
In 2014, three researchers at the University of Michigan, Scott Rick, Beatriz Pereira and Katherine Burson, published a study with a plain title: The benefits of retail therapy. They ran three experiments. They put people in a sad mood, then gave some of them shopping choices to make and others a different task.
The people who got to choose things to buy came out less sad. Shopping really did help. That part matched the folk wisdom.
Here is the part that did not. In the first experiment the shopping was hypothetical. Nobody bought anything. People just picked what they would buy. And the sadness eased anyway. The researchers found that the mechanism was not owning a new thing. It was getting back a sense of control.
Sadness, they explain, tends to come with a feeling that life is being done to you. Things happen and you cannot steer them. Picking between two jackets is a tiny act of steering. It says: I decide this. That small bit of control is what lifts the mood.
They found one more thing worth knowing. The effect did not work on anger. Anger comes with a different belief, that some person is causing the problem. Choosing a jacket does not touch that. So if you are shopping because you are furious at someone, the research says the cart will not help, even for a minute.
Read that study slowly and the headline changes. The medicine was never the box. The medicine was the choosing. The box was just the receipt for it.
Why the Waiting Does Not Feel Like Much
You might expect the days between the click and the doorbell to be the fun part. The looking forward. For things, that turns out to be mostly flat.
Also in 2014, researchers at Cornell University ran a set of studies on anticipation, with a title that is hard to forget: Waiting for Merlot. They compared people waiting for an experience, like a trip or a meal out, with people waiting for a possession.
Waiting for experiences felt good. People were in better moods and, in a review of news stories about queues, they even behaved better while standing in line. But when the team checked in with people across ordinary days, thinking about a future thing they planned to buy did not lift their mood compared with the moments they were not thinking about it. Thinking about a future experience did.
So the curve has a shape. A lift at the moment of choosing. Then a long flat stretch while the thing travels toward you. The tracking page is not doing for your mood what you hoped.
Why the Package Itself Feels Like Nothing
Then the box comes, and within a day or two the new thing is just your thing. Your brain is very good at this. Its job is to make new things normal as fast as possible so it can pay attention to what is next.
A 2009 study in the Journal of Consumer Research compared how fast people get used to things versus experiences. People adapted more quickly to the material purchases. The shoes become the shoes you own. The memory of a day out keeps its colour longer, for better and, when the day went badly, for worse.
None of this means you chose wrong. It means you are built this way. The flat feeling on the kitchen table is not a verdict on the jacket or on you. It is just the curve finishing.
How to Keep the Good Part and Skip the Box
If the relief lives in the choosing, you can reach for it on purpose. None of these cost anything.
- Build the cart, then close the app. The study’s imagined shopping eased sadness without a purchase. Pick your favourites. Compare them. Decide. Then leave it there. You have already had the part that works.
- Ask which feeling it is. Sad or angry? If it is anger at a person, the research says shopping will not touch it. A walk, a hard conversation, or writing the thing down will do more than any sale.
- Choose something else. Control is the ingredient, not the price tag. Rearrange one shelf. Pick tomorrow’s route. Cook the thing you actually want tonight. Small decisions you steer yourself seem to do the same work.
- Put a gap between seeing and taking. Checkout screens are built to shrink that gap. We wrote about how to stop impulse buying by widening it again, and every step in there is free.
- Notice the flatness without judging it. When the box comes and you feel nothing, say so to yourself. Not “I wasted money” but “there it is, the curve.” Naming it takes the sting out, and it makes the next cart a little easier to close.
If you notice the shopping has turned into a habit tied to worry about the future rather than a bad afternoon, that has its own name, and we looked at it in what doom spending is and why it is hard to stop. And if you are curious about your own pattern with money, the free What Is My Money Personality? quiz takes a couple of minutes and gives you something honest to look at.
The Oldest Notes on This Curve
What struck me, reading these studies, is how old the observation is. One of the oldest books of wisdom in the world, written long before anyone had a shopping cart, says almost exactly what the researchers found: the person who loves money is never satisfied by money. Then the writer adds a strange, honest detail that most people read straight past. When possessions pile up, all the owner really gets out of them is to look at them.
That is not a scolding. It reads like someone who tried it and took notes. The writer had the stuff, had the flat feeling on the table, and wrote down what it was like. And the quiet point underneath is that the control you were reaching for in the cart was never something you could buy. The hunger under the shopping might be pointing somewhere bigger than the shop. We looked at that same ancient line in why more money never feels like enough, if you want to sit with it longer.
Before the Sales Start
The big late-November sales are a couple of weeks away, Black Friday in many countries, and the apps already know it. You will feel the pull. That is fine. You are allowed to want things, and some of them you genuinely need.
But now you know where the good part lives. It is in the choosing, and it is yours for free. The box was never the medicine. So build the cart. Enjoy picking. And when you can, close the app and keep the part that worked.
Something to Think About
Do you think the “build the cart, then close it” idea could actually replace a real purchase for you, or does the relief need the real thing? Tell us what you have noticed in the comments.
Share This
“A 2014 study found retail therapy works even when you don’t buy anything. The relief is in the choosing, not the box. Read this before the sales start: https://bgodinspired.com/index.php/personal-growth-and-life-skills/why-retail-therapy-feels-good-until-the-package-arrives/”
“Finally understand why the package always feels flat when it arrives. It’s not me, it’s the curve. https://bgodinspired.com/index.php/personal-growth-and-life-skills/why-retail-therapy-feels-good-until-the-package-arrives/”
“Retail therapy doesn’t work on anger, only on sadness. Who knew. Good read: https://bgodinspired.com/index.php/personal-growth-and-life-skills/why-retail-therapy-feels-good-until-the-package-arrives/”
Questions People Ask About Retail Therapy
Does retail therapy actually work?
Yes, for sadness. A 2014 study from the University of Michigan found that making shopping choices reduced sadness in three experiments. The effect came from restoring a sense of personal control, not from owning a new item, and it worked even when the shopping was only imagined.
Why does retail therapy not help when I am angry?
The same 2014 study found that shopping choices did not reduce anger. Anger comes with the belief that another person caused the problem, and choosing what to buy does not change that belief, so the small sense of control that eases sadness does nothing for anger.
Why do I feel nothing when my online order arrives?
People adapt to material possessions quickly. A 2009 study in the Journal of Consumer Research found that people got used to things faster than they got used to experiences. The emotional lift from shopping happens at the moment of choosing, so by the time a package arrives the brain has often already moved on.
Is retail therapy a sign of a bigger problem?
An occasional purchase to lift a bad day is normal and the research shows it does help a little. It becomes a concern when it is the only tool for low moods, when it is driven by worry about the future rather than a bad afternoon, or when it creates debt. A free alternative is to make the choices in the cart and then close it without buying.
What can I do instead of retail therapy when I feel low?
Anything that gives back a small sense of control. Build a shopping cart and close it without buying, rearrange a shelf, plan tomorrow, or cook the meal you actually want. The research points to the act of choosing as the ingredient, so any decision you steer yourself can do similar work without costing anything.
