Frederick County School Board Race: Book Availability Sparks Debate Among Candidates
By Adam Hudacek and Tolu Talabi | Local News Network
In the heated arena of Maryland’s school board elections, candidates are grappling with a key question: What material should be available to students in their school libraries? This inquiry, however, is more than a mere debate; it’s a reflection of deeper values about education, freedom, and moral responsibility.
Colt Black, a candidate for the Frederick County Public School Board, embodies this complexity. Not only is he a mortician, emergency medical technician, and firefighter, but he also considers himself a “First Amendment absolutist.” When it comes to book bans, Black firmly opposes them, yet maintains that any book intended for school libraries should undergo rigorous review by a committee to ensure it aligns with academic and age-appropriate standards.
“I don’t support book bans,” Black expressed. However, he proposes a process where books containing extreme violence or sexually explicit content—deemed as lacking academic value—should be excluded after public hearings. This nuanced view resonates with approximately 38 of the 74 respondents in a recent Local News Network survey, indicating a widespread willingness among candidates to establish a framework for reviewing book content without outright bans.
A significant drive for policy change stems from a growing movement led by conservative groups like Moms for Liberty, which have pressed for more stringent book reviews based on parental concerns over content. However, contrasting voices emerge from candidates like Sarah J. McDermott, advocating for the trust in educators and librarians to make sound decisions regarding age-appropriate materials without censorship.
As discussions unfold, underlying themes emerge that echo biblical principles of discernment, accountability, and stewardship of knowledge. In Proverbs 4:7, it reads: “The beginning of wisdom is this: Get wisdom. Though it cost all you have, get understanding.” This verse invites us to reflect on the importance of not only access to knowledge but also the wisdom to discern what is beneficial for our youth.
Adding another layer, the recently passed Freedom to Read Act aims to counter book bans by ensuring materials can’t be removed from school libraries solely due to the author’s background or ideological views. While this law strives for inclusivity, critics argue it overlooks the majority of recently banned books, effectively leaving local policies in place that can sidestep the state legislation.
In light of this legislative landscape, Carroll County stands out as a cautionary tale, reporting over 60 book removals, with 21 permanently banned titles, including works focused on LGBTQ+ themes and topics of sexual abuse. The context of these removals raises essential questions about who gets to decide what knowledge is appropriate and the values that guide these decisions.
As we approach the upcoming elections, it becomes crucial to engage in these discussions, recognizing our shared responsibility to foster a learning environment that promotes understanding, respect, and wisdom—principles that resonate with many faith traditions.
In a world where conflicts over educational materials are becoming increasingly polarized, it’s essential to remember the importance of dialogue and compassion. After all, as Jesus taught in Matthew 7:12, “So in everything, do to others what you would have them do to you; for this sums up the Law and the Prophets.”
Whether one stands in favor of protective measures for students or advocates for unfettered access to diverse materials, the underlying call remains: to seek understanding and guidance in decisions that will shape future generations.
As voters prepare for the polls, let us reflect on the broader spiritual lesson here: wise stewardship of knowledge is not just about access; it is about nurturing a culture of discernment and respect for diverse perspectives in our communities. How might we engage with each other more thoughtfully as we navigate this critical issue? Let this question guide our conversations in the days to come.
Explore and dig up answers yourself with our BGodInspired Bible Tools! Be careful – each interaction is like a new treasure hunt… you can get lost for hours 🙂
